Killing Bhishma

Inner defences that outlive their purpose

← All notes
The People

The Teacher Who Trained Both Armies

Nearly every great commander on both sides of the Mahabharata war learned to fight from the same man. He taught the five and he taught the hundred, in the same courtyard, and the epic does not treat this as an irony.

Anurag JoshiAuthor, Killing Bhishma29 Jun 20267 min read

Here is a fact about the Mahabharata that is strange enough to stop on, and that the epic itself passes over almost without comment: nearly every great commander on both sides of that war learned to fight from the same man. Same courtyard, same drills, same devotion. His students then spent eighteen days killing each other with what he had given them.

The insult he never put down

Drona was born poor and brilliant. As a boy he had a friend, a prince named Drupada, who once promised him half a kingdom the way boys promise things. Years later, in need, Drona went to that kingdom to collect on it — and was told, from the throne, in front of the court, that friendship exists only between equals, and that a king and a beggar are not friends.

He walked out carrying that afternoon like a second spine, and eventually arrived at Hastinapura, where the royal house hired him to make warriors of its princes. The epic never wastes a wound, and it does not waste this one.

Both sets of cousins, taught properly

He trained the five. He trained the hundred. He also trained the boy who would one day command the army against him, the prince who would eventually behead him, and every archer of consequence in the coming war. Nothing in the epic suggests he taught either side badly, or held anything back from students he could reasonably expect to face later. He taught them all properly.

The famous test belongs to this courtyard: a wooden bird set on a branch, and each student asked in turn what he could see. The tree, said one. The branch. The bird. Only one student answered that he could see the eye of the bird and nothing else — and that student got the arrow, and the reputation, and the teacher's love.

The boy at the gate

And there was one he would not teach at all. A forest boy came to the academy gate asking for lessons in archery and was refused; the rules said princes, and he was not one. So he went back into the forest, built a clay likeness of the teacher who had turned him away, set it up, and trained in front of it for years, alone — until he was better than the prince Drona had sworn to make the finest archer alive.

When Drona found out, he did not celebrate. He asked the boy for the customary fee owed to a teacher. He asked for his right thumb, and the boy gave it, and the finest natural archer of that generation never drew properly again. Nothing in the epic softens this scene either. It is recorded, and the story goes on.

How he actually fell

On the fifteenth day of the war he was unstoppable, and nobody on the field could out-fight him. So the other side did something else. They let him hear that his son Ashwatthama was dead.

It was technically a half-truth — an elephant of that name had fallen — and the epic marks the cost of even that half-truth with one of its most unsettling small details: the chariot of the man who spoke it, which had always floated a little above the earth because he had never lied, came down and touched the ground as the words left him.

And Drona stopped. In the middle of a battle, at the height of his own slaughter, the deadliest man alive laid his weapons down in the chariot and sat with his eyes closed. Not defeated. Told that the thing his whole life's skill had been earned for no longer existed.

It was not his greatest student who took his head — a student cannot finish the teacher. It was Dhrishtadyumna, who had come out of a great fire sacrifice performed by a humiliated king for precisely one purpose: a son born to end Drona. Out of that same fire, in the same hour, came his sister, Draupadi.

The line worth keeping

The epic does not present any of this as a tragedy or an irony. It simply records it and moves on. He taught them all properly, and then he took the field against half of them, and every skill used against him that day was his own.

Written by Anurag JoshiAuthor, Killing Bhishma. Notes kept while the book was being written.

Whenever you're ready

The book walks the rest of the field.

No seven steps. No morning routine. No twenty-one days.

Be there when it arrives